Alberto Cairo: “Data journalism will change this profession for the better”Posted: 02/03/2014
Alberto Cairo is a professor of Information Graphics and Visualization at the School of Communication at the University of Miami, where he is also the director of the Visualization Program at the UM’s Center for Computational Science. He has written two books: Infografía 2.0: Visualización interactiva de información en prensa (Alamut, Spain, 2008) and The Functional Art: an Introduction to Information Graphics and Visualization (PeachPit Press, 2012). In 2000, Cairo led the creation of the Interactive Infographics Department at El Mundo, the second largest newspaper in Spain, and one of the pioneers in embracing data visualization.
Why did you decide to become an expert in data journalism?
My knowledge of data comes mainly from studying on my own a little bit of statistics and the scientific method, but I don’t usually call myself a data journalist. I feel that goes beyond my area of expertise, although somehow my work is related to data journalism, but I’m not so good at using databases, extracting stories from databases or dealing with complex mathematical operations. I know my stats, but I’m not an expert.
I became interested in information graphics and visualization because I studied Journalism in Spain a number of years ago, and then I got an internship at a local newspaper there which was looking for people who had a background in Journalism but who could also draw a little bit. I’m not a great artist, but I know how to sketch ideas, so they hired me and then I got in love with the possibilities of this field, the possibilities of conveying ideas and complex information by means of diagrams, charts, graphs and maps, etc. I am basically selft-trained like almost everybody else in this industry.
How would you say the rise of data journalism in the era of digital media has affected to journalism?
I could prefer to call it data-driven journalism or evidence-based journalism. The latter is the label that I have coined and I am trying to promote lately. Many people would think that this is a contradiction, that all journalism is based on evidence, but I would disagree with that. Many journalists out there do not know what evidence means. They are not able to use statistical methods of analysis, for instance. They do not even know that the scientific method is and that is a huge issue, so even if they say that all their work is based on evidence, that is not actually true. They are being affected by things like cognitive biases or their own political and cultural biases, even if they are not very aware of that, and they are not able to double-check or to put their preconceived ideas under control by looking at data and evidence.
The current popularity of people like [the American statistician] Nate Silver or other famous data journalists is actually extremely positive to journalism, because it is prompting a change in the curricula of journalism schools and it is also driving changes in newsrooms. More and more newsrooms are creating small teams of data journalists, statisticians, and information & visualization designers that will somehow in the future make the whole profession of journalism change for the better. They will increase the awareness of how important statistic and analytical methods are for journalism.
Which are the characteristics that a good data visualization should accomplish?
Which software would you recommend to journalists starting to embrace data journalism skills?
It depends on what you want to focus on. If you are going to focus just on writing , it is obvious that you will need to get acquainted with software related to databases, so learn jQuery, how to use Google Fusion Tables, Access and Excel or their open source alternatives. Those are going to be extremely important. But the tools are not enough. If you take a look at the handbooks about data journalism you will see that they focus too much on the tools, and they do not focus enough, in my opinion, on the concepts. So if you want to get into data journalism you do need to get solid training on statistics. You can be self-trained in stats and quantitative methods of analysis, there are many resources out there, like the massive online courses that you can get at Coursera and tons of books that can give you the foundations that you need. Those are much more important than the software tools.
According to your opinion, which is the most common mistake among data journalists?
News editors are one of the most reactionary species I’ve ever met. They believe that too many of us, visualization designers, are too focused on being creative rather than on being clear. Having worked in newsrooms for many years, I have observed the following attitude many times: “Oh, I like this new, cool graphic form, let’s use it; Oh, I like this typeface or this color palette…”, rather than thinking about if that graphic form, typeface, or color palette ﬁts the purpose of your visualization. The desire to be creative, as respectful and admirable as it might be, doesn’t free us from the obligation of respecting what the human visual brain can or can’t do. Any innovation must happen within certain constrains imposed by human visual perception and cognition. If the goal of the graphic is to let readers compare, shape your data in a way that allows for accurate comparisons.